Ice Cream & Frozen Dairy Desserts

Dairy Science & Technology · Dairy Processing & Product Technology · also Ice Cream Technology, Frozen Desserts

11units
11chapters
5,235words
94practice questions

Mix formulation and calculation, freezing, overrun, hardening and the structure and defects of ice cream and related products.

In the exams: ICAR AICE subject 34 Unit 8 and subject 37 Unit 1; GATE XL-U Section 3 (ice cream)

Syllabus

  1. Classes of frozen desserts and their standards
  2. Ice cream ingredients and their functions
  3. Mix calculation: serum point and algebraic methods
  4. Mix processing: pasteurisation, homogenisation and ageing
  5. Freezing: batch and continuous freezers
  6. Overrun calculation and control
  7. Hardening, storage and heat shock
  8. Ice cream structure: ice crystals, air cells, fat network
  9. Kulfi, frozen yoghurt, sherbet and frozen confections
  10. Reduced-fat and reduced-sugar ice cream
  11. Defects and their causes

Study manual

Ice cream and related frozen desserts are among the most technically complex dairy products. A good ice cream is at the same time an emulsion, a foam, a suspension of ice crystals and a freeze-concentrated sugar solution, and its quality depends on getting all four right from formulation through freezing, hardening and the last mile to the consumer's freezer. Small changes in fat, milk solids, sugars, stabilisers or temperature history show up as iciness, sandiness, butteriness, shrinkage or poor melting.

This manual covers the classes of frozen desserts and their standards; ingredients and their functions; mix calculation by the serum point rule and algebra; mix processing by pasteurisation, homogenisation and ageing; batch and continuous freezing; overrun; hardening, storage and heat shock; the structure of ice cream; kulfi, frozen yoghurt, sherbet and frozen confections; reduced-fat and reduced-sugar products; and defects. Pasteurisation and homogenisation equipment is described in market-milk-processing, and refrigeration engineering in the dairy refrigeration subject; this manual refers to them rather than repeating them.

ICAR AICE-JRF/SRF Dairy Chemistry (subject 34, Unit 8) asks for ice cream composition and structure, changes during ageing, freezing and hardening, defects, the role of stabilisers and emulsifiers, and kulfi; Dairy Technology (subject 37, Unit 1) covers frozen desserts. GATE XL Food Technology includes ice cream in milk products processing. Compositional standards and permitted additives differ by country; values in this manual are textbook or named-standard examples and must be checked against the current regulation.

1. Classes of frozen desserts and their standards

The product family

Frozen dairy desserts are aerated, partly frozen emulsions made from a pasteurised mix of milk solids, fat, sugars, stabilisers and emulsifiers. The family includes ice cream in its many grades, frozen custard (with egg yolk), soft-serve, frozen yoghurt, sherbet, kulfi and other traditional products, and novelties such as stick bars and coated cones. Non-dairy relatives include sorbets and water ices, which contain no milk solids, and frozen desserts made with vegetable fat. The same physical principles — freezing point depression, ice crystallisation, air incorporation and fat destabilisation — govern all of them, but legal names depend on composition, and the rules differ widely between countries.

Standards in major markets

In the United States, the federal standard of identity for ice cream requires at least 10 per cent milk fat and at least 20 per cent total milk solids (with some substitution of milk fat for non-fat solids allowed), a minimum weight of 4.5 pounds per gallon and a minimum food solids content per gallon; frozen custard or French ice cream must also contain at least 1.4 per cent egg yolk solids. Sherbet contains between 1 and 2 per cent milk fat and between 2 and 5 per cent total milk solids. Nutrient-content terms such as reduced fat, light, low fat and nonfat are defined relative to a reference product or per serving. The European Union has no harmonised ice cream standard; member states and trade codes set their own, and in the United Kingdom 'dairy ice cream' must contain milk fat and milk protein at specified minimums while 'ice cream' may contain vegetable fat. In India, food standards define ice cream, kulfi and related products by minimum milk fat, milk protein, total solids and weight per volume, with lower-fat classes; products made with vegetable fat must be called 'frozen dessert' or 'frozen confection' rather than ice cream. The values must always be taken from the current regulation of the market of sale.

Weight-per-volume limits matter because they cap overrun: a minimum weight per litre, together with the mix density, sets the maximum air that can be incorporated. Some standards add microbiological criteria for coliforms and pathogens, because ice cream is a ready-to-eat food with no kill step after packing.

Microbiological and labelling requirements

Because frozen desserts are eaten without further heating and can carry pathogens that survive freezing, many standards set microbiological criteria for mix and finished product, commonly limits for total plate count, coliforms or Enterobacteriaceae and the absence of pathogens such as Listeria monocytogenes and Salmonella in defined sample sizes. Labelling rules require the product name as defined by the standard, an ingredient list with allergens (milk, egg, nuts, gluten from wafers and inclusions), net quantity (often by volume and sometimes weight), nutrition information and storage instructions such as 'do not refreeze once thawed'. Claims like 'made with real cream', 'no added sugar' or 'low fat' must match the relevant definitions.

Remember

2. Ice cream ingredients and their functions

Fat, milk solids-not-fat and sugars

Milk fat (commonly about 10–16 per cent, higher in premium products) gives richness, smoothness and flavour, and during freezing forms a partly coalesced network that stabilises the air cells. Sources include cream, butter, anhydrous milk fat and, in non-dairy-fat frozen desserts, vegetable fats. Milk solids-not-fat (MSNF, commonly about 9–12 per cent) supply protein, which emulsifies fat, aids whipping and adds body, and lactose and minerals. MSNF cannot be raised indefinitely: lactose is poorly soluble and, if too concentrated in the unfrozen serum during storage, crystallises as sandy, gritty crystals. Sources include skim milk, condensed skim, skim milk powder, milk protein concentrates and whey products.

Sugars (commonly about 12–16 per cent sucrose or equivalent) sweeten, add body and, critically, depress the freezing point so that the ice cream is scoopable at storage temperature. Sucrose is the reference; corn (glucose) syrup solids add body and chew with less sweetness and less freezing-point depression per gram than sucrose, while dextrose and fructose depress the freezing point more and make the product softer. Formulators use 'sucrose equivalence' for sweetness and 'freezing point depression factors' for softness, balancing the two.

Stabilisers, emulsifiers and other ingredients

Stabilisers are hydrocolloids used at low levels (typically a few tenths of a per cent) to increase mix viscosity, bind water in the unfrozen phase, slow ice recrystallisation during storage and give a smooth body and slow melt. Common ones are guar gum, locust bean gum, sodium carboxymethylcellulose, sodium alginate and gelatin. Carrageenan is used as a secondary stabiliser because it prevents the 'wheying off' (serum separation) that other gums can cause in mix by incompatibility with milk proteins.

Emulsifiers — mainly mono- and diglycerides and polysorbate 80 — are used at even lower levels. Despite the name, their main role in ice cream is to destabilise the emulsion in a controlled way: they displace protein from the fat globule surface during ageing, so that globules partially coalesce during freezing and whipping. This gives a drier ice cream at the freezer outlet, better shape retention, smoother texture and slower melting. Too much emulsifier causes excessive coalescence and a buttery defect. Egg yolk, a traditional ingredient, acts as an emulsifier through its lecithin. Flavours, colours, fruits, nuts, cocoa, chocolate and inclusions complete the product; acid fruits may need adjustment to avoid curdling, and particulates must be safe because there is no later kill step.

Choosing sweeteners

Sucrose remains the standard sweetener because it gives clean sweetness, good body and a predictable freezing point. Glucose (corn) syrups are classified by dextrose equivalent (DE): low-DE syrups contain more long-chain saccharides, add body and chewiness, raise the glass transition of the freeze-concentrated serum and slow recrystallisation, but are less sweet and depress the freezing point less; high-DE syrups behave more like dextrose. Dextrose (glucose) is about three-quarters as sweet as sucrose but, being a smaller molecule, depresses the freezing point roughly twice as much per gram, making ice cream softer at the same temperature. Fructose and invert sugar are sweeter and also strongly freezing-point depressing. Lactose from milk solids contributes little sweetness but does depress the freezing point, and its low solubility sets the MSNF limit. Honey, maple syrup, jaggery and other flavoured sugars are used in speciality products, with their own freezing behaviour. Formulators therefore treat sweetness and softness as two separate targets and combine sweeteners to meet both, together with cost and labelling goals such as 'no added sugar'.

Remember

3. Mix calculation: serum point and algebraic methods

Setting the formula

A mix is specified by its percentage composition, for example 12 per cent fat, 11 per cent MSNF, 15 per cent sugar and 0.3 per cent stabiliser-emulsifier blend, giving 38.3 per cent total solids. The calculation finds the masses of available ingredients (cream, milk, skim milk powder, condensed milk, butter, sugar, stabiliser, water) that give that composition. Each ingredient contributes to one or more components: cream supplies fat and some MSNF, skim milk powder supplies MSNF, sugar supplies sugar, and water dilutes. Before calculating, the formulator checks that the MSNF chosen is safe against sandiness; a common guide, the serum point rule, limits MSNF to a fixed fraction of the serum (the part of the mix that is not fat, sugar or other added solids). One widely used version takes MSNF as about 17 per cent of that serum, i.e. MSNF ≈ 0.17 × (100 − fat − sugar − stabiliser and emulsifier); other versions use slightly different factors, so the factor must be stated in any calculation.

Algebraic method with a worked example

For simple mixes the components can be satisfied one at a time. Example: 100 kg of mix at 12 per cent fat, 11 per cent MSNF, 15 per cent sugar and 0.3 per cent stabiliser from cream (40 per cent fat, 5.4 per cent MSNF), skim milk powder (97 per cent MSNF), sugar, stabiliser and water. Fat comes only from cream: cream = 12 ÷ 0.40 = 30 kg, which brings 30 × 0.054 = 1.62 kg MSNF. The remaining MSNF, 11 − 1.62 = 9.38 kg, comes from powder: 9.38 ÷ 0.97 = 9.67 kg. Sugar is 15 kg and stabiliser 0.3 kg. Water makes up the rest: 100 − 30 − 9.67 − 15 − 0.3 = 45.03 kg. The answer is checked by summing each component.

When two ingredients both supply two components (for example cream and whole milk both supplying fat and MSNF), simultaneous equations are written: a fat balance, an MSNF balance and a total mass balance, solved together. The Pearson square handles one component and two ingredients only. Spreadsheet or software mix calculators do the same algebra, often with cost minimisation and constraints on freezing point and sweetness.

Freezing point and sweetness checks

A mix that meets the composition can still be too hard or too soft at the storage temperature. Freezing point depression depends on the number of dissolved molecules in the water of the mix: mainly sugars, lactose and salts. Formulators calculate an equivalent sucrose content per 100 g of water and read the freezing point from published curves, or use freezing point depression factors relative to sucrose for each sweetener (for example, dextrose depresses the freezing point roughly twice as much as sucrose per gram, while high-molecular-weight glucose syrup solids depress it much less). Sweetness is checked in the same way with relative sweetness factors. These checks matter most when replacing sugar, fat or milk solids.

Using other ingredients in the calculation

Real plants rarely use only cream, powder, sugar and water. Whole milk, condensed skim milk, sweetened condensed milk, butter, anhydrous milk fat, whey powders and milk protein concentrates are all common, chosen on price and availability. Each must be described by its fat, MSNF, sugar and total solids. Butter supplies fat (around 80 per cent) with a little MSNF; sweetened condensed milk supplies fat, MSNF and sucrose at once; whey powders supply lactose-rich MSNF that can increase sandiness if overused. When more ingredients than components are available, there are many possible solutions, and the cheapest that meets the composition and quality constraints is chosen, which is a linear-programming problem solved by commercial mix-formulation software. Whatever the method, the plant must also allow for losses in processing, for flavourings and inclusions that dilute the mix, and for the moisture in powders, and it should verify each batch by laboratory analysis of fat and total solids.

Remember

4. Mix processing: pasteurisation, homogenisation and ageing

Blending and pasteurisation

Liquid ingredients are blended and warmed, and dry ingredients (powder, sugar, stabiliser premixed with sugar to avoid lumps) are dispersed with high-shear mixers. The mix is pasteurised, either in batch at a lower temperature for a long time or continuously by HTST. Because the mix is high in solids, which protect micro-organisms, regulations require higher conditions than for milk: the U.S. Pasteurized Milk Ordinance, for example, specifies 68.3 °C (155 °F) for 30 minutes in vat pasteurisation and 79.4 °C (175 °F) for 25 seconds by HTST for frozen dessert mix, with higher-temperature options. Pasteurisation also hydrates stabilisers, dissolves ingredients and, at higher temperatures, denatures some whey protein, which can improve whipping and body. Some plants use UHT for long-life mixes, especially for soft-serve.

Homogenisation

The hot mix is homogenised, usually in two stages, at pressures lower for high-fat mixes than for low-fat ones because high-fat mixes are prone to fat clustering. Homogenisation reduces fat globules to about 1 µm or less, so the fat emulsion is stable in the mix; creates new fat surface covered by milk proteins; increases viscosity and smoothness; and makes the globules available for controlled partial coalescence during freezing. The second stage breaks up clusters formed in the first. Inadequate homogenisation gives a greasy, buttery ice cream with large fat particles; homogenising at too low a temperature gives clustering.

Ageing

After cooling to about 4 °C or below, the mix is aged, commonly for at least about four hours and often overnight. During ageing the fat crystallises (partial coalescence needs crystalline fat), the stabilisers hydrate fully and raise viscosity, and the emulsifiers displace proteins from the fat globule surface, so that the membrane becomes thinner and weaker. Aged mix whips more easily, gives a drier, stiffer product at the freezer outlet, melts more slowly and has a smoother body. Ageing tanks must be kept cold and clean, because the mix is an excellent growth medium; flavours and colours are often added at this stage, while acid fruits and particulates are added at the freezer.

Hygiene of the mix

Ice cream mix is rich in sugar, protein and fat, nearly neutral in pH, and held for hours in ageing tanks: an ideal medium for bacteria if contaminated after pasteurisation. Because there is no later kill step, the ageing tanks, transfer lines, freezers, ingredient feeders and fillers must be cleaned and sanitised to the same standard as any ready-to-eat food plant, with cleaning validated by swabs and environmental monitoring for Listeria and Enterobacteriaceae. Ingredients added after pasteurisation (fruit preparations, nuts, chocolate pieces, sauces) must be supplied as safe for direct addition, with supplier certificates and testing. Mix should be cooled quickly after pasteurisation and held at about 4 °C or below. Rework from filling stoppages and returned product needs controlled handling; rework containing allergens such as nuts must be kept out of products that do not declare them.

Remember

5. Freezing: batch and continuous freezers

The dynamic freezing step

Freezing in the freezer (dynamic freezing) does three things at once: it freezes part of the water into many small ice crystals, it incorporates air, and it destabilises the fat. The freezer is a scraped-surface heat exchanger: a jacketed cylinder cooled by evaporating refrigerant (ammonia or a halocarbon), with a rotating dasher carrying scraper blades. Ice forms on the cold wall and is scraped off immediately, so new nuclei form continuously and crystals stay small; the dasher whips air into the mix and its shear breaks fat globules against each other and against air bubbles, driving partial coalescence. The product leaves at the draw temperature, commonly about −5 to −6 °C from continuous freezers, with roughly a third to a half of its water frozen. Colder draw temperatures give more ice already formed in small crystals and finer final texture, but stiffer product that is harder to pump and fill.

Batch and continuous freezers

Batch freezers take a fixed charge of mix, freeze and whip it for a set time, and discharge it. Overrun is controlled by time and dasher speed and is limited (typically lower than in continuous freezers); draw temperatures are often warmer. They are used for small shops, artisanal gelato and specialities. Continuous freezers pump mix and metered air into the cylinder under pressure; the air is dispersed into fine bubbles and the product leaves continuously. Overrun is set accurately by the ratio of air to mix flow, and output is high. Ingredients such as fruit, nuts and ripples are added after the freezer in ingredient feeders and variegating pumps. Low-temperature extrusion, in which the product from a conventional freezer passes through a cooled screw extruder to reach about −12 to −15 °C before filling, freezes more water under shear and gives smaller ice crystals and air cells, better heat-shock stability and less hardening load. Soft-serve is drawn from small freezers at a warmer temperature and eaten immediately.

Air and freezer variables

In a continuous freezer, air is metered into the mix stream under pressure before the barrel; the dasher disperses it into fine cells, and the back-pressure at the outlet keeps the air compressed during freezing so that it expands as the product leaves. Freezer variables interact: increasing refrigerant capacity lowers the draw temperature and stiffens the product; increasing dasher speed raises shear and fat destabilisation but also adds frictional heat; increasing throughput shortens residence time and gives a warmer, wetter product. Mix variables matter as much: higher total solids and protein improve air incorporation, aged mix with well-chosen emulsifier gives drier extrusion, and over-stabilised mixes whip slowly. Operators set the freezer to hit a target overrun and draw temperature, and check the 'dryness' of the extruded ribbon, which reflects fat destabilisation. Air must be clean, filtered and free of oil, since it becomes a large part of the product volume.

Remember

6. Overrun calculation and control

Definitions

Overrun is the increase in volume of ice cream over the volume of mix used, expressed as a percentage of the mix volume: overrun = (volume of ice cream − volume of mix) ÷ volume of mix × 100. It can also be calculated by weight from the weights of equal volumes: overrun = (weight of a volume of mix − weight of the same volume of ice cream) ÷ weight of the same volume of ice cream × 100. For example, if a litre of mix weighs 1.10 kg and a litre of ice cream weighs 0.55 kg, the overrun is (1.10 − 0.55) ÷ 0.55 × 100 = 100 per cent: the ice cream is half air by volume. The weight method is used in plants by weighing a standard cup of mix and of ice cream. The weight per litre of ice cream = mix density ÷ (1 + overrun ÷ 100).

Typical values and control

Overrun varies widely by product. Premium and super-premium ice creams commonly have low overrun (around 25–50 per cent), standard packaged ice creams around 80–100 per cent or more, soft-serve around 30–50 per cent, and kulfi essentially none. Higher overrun lowers the cost per litre but gives a lighter, colder-feeling, less flavourful product that melts faster and is more prone to shrinkage; too low an overrun gives a heavy, soggy product. Legal minimum weights per volume cap overrun: with a mix density of 1.10 kg per litre and a minimum of 525 g per litre, for example, overrun cannot exceed 1.10 ÷ 0.525 − 1 = 109.5 per cent.

Overrun is controlled by the air flow and mix flow in continuous freezers, by the freezing time and dasher speed in batch freezers, and by the mix itself: total solids, protein, emulsifier, stabiliser and ageing all affect how well the mix whips and holds air. Regular checks by weighing cups at the filler keep overrun within specification, protecting both legal compliance and margin.

Remember

7. Hardening, storage and heat shock

Hardening

Ice cream leaving the freezer is soft. Packed products are hardened quickly to a low temperature, commonly to a core temperature of about −18 °C or below, in hardening tunnels with cold air at around −30 to −40 °C, in plate hardeners, or in hardening rooms. During hardening much more of the water freezes, mostly by growth of the existing crystals rather than by forming new ones; this is why fast hardening is important: slow hardening allows fewer, larger crystals and a coarser texture. The hardening load is large because the latent heat of fusion of water (about 334 kJ/kg) must be removed for every kilogram of water frozen after the freezer. Smaller packages harden faster; low-temperature extrusion reduces the load.

Storage and distribution

Ice cream is stored and distributed at about −18 °C or below, often colder in central stores (−25 °C or so), and displayed in retail cabinets at slightly warmer temperatures for scooping. The key enemy is temperature fluctuation, or heat shock. When the temperature rises, the smallest ice crystals melt; when it falls again, the water refreezes onto the larger crystals rather than forming new ones. Over many cycles, the mean crystal size grows (recrystallisation, including Ostwald ripening and accretion), and the ice cream becomes coarse and icy. Lactose may crystallise in the freeze-concentrated serum (sandiness), air cells coarsen and coalesce, and the product may shrink. Heat shock happens during transport, in retail cabinets with defrost cycles, and in home freezers and on the way home. Stabilisers slow, but do not prevent, recrystallisation; good cold-chain management is the real defence.

Freeze concentration and the glass transition

As ice forms, the remaining unfrozen serum becomes more concentrated in sugars, lactose, salts and stabilisers, and its freezing point falls. Even at −18 °C a significant fraction of the water remains unfrozen in this concentrated syrup, which is why ice cream can be scooped. If the temperature is low enough, the serum reaches a glassy state at the glass transition of the maximally freeze-concentrated solution, below which molecular mobility, recrystallisation and other changes become extremely slow. Typical ice cream storage temperatures are above this transition for most formulations, so changes continue slowly; formulation with higher-molecular-weight sugars and stabilisers raises the transition temperature and improves stability.

Cold-chain practice

Good cold-chain practice for frozen desserts starts at the hardening tunnel exit: product should go straight into a cold store at a stable low temperature, on pallets arranged so that cold air circulates. Doors are kept closed with air curtains or strip curtains, defrost cycles are scheduled and monitored, and stock rotates first-in, first-out. Refrigerated vehicles are pre-cooled before loading, loading is fast, and deliveries are planned to limit door openings. Retail cabinets should be loaded below the load line, kept away from heat sources and not overfilled, and their temperature recorded. Data loggers placed with product show where temperature excursions happen. Each excursion causes some irreversible ice crystal growth, so the number and size of excursions, not only the average temperature, determine quality at the point of consumption. Consumer advice on packs to take the product home quickly and store it in the coldest part of the freezer is part of this chain.

Remember

8. Ice cream structure: ice crystals, air cells, fat network

A partly frozen foam

Ice cream is a complex colloid: a partly frozen foam with ice crystals, air cells and partly coalesced fat dispersed in a continuous, freeze-concentrated unfrozen serum that contains dissolved sugars, proteins, stabilisers and lactose. Each element contributes to quality. Ice crystals, typically a few tens of micrometres across in fresh, well-made ice cream, give the cold, refreshing sensation; when they grow larger the product is perceived as coarse or icy. Air cells, of a similar order of size, make the product light and soft and insulate it so that it does not feel too cold; their stability depends on the fat and protein around them. Fat globules, partly coalesced into clusters and chains, adsorb at the air cell surfaces and extend into the serum, forming a network that stabilises the air cells, gives dryness at the freezer outlet, stiffness and shape retention, and a slow, smooth melt. Proteins adsorb at the air and fat interfaces; stabilisers increase the serum viscosity and limit ice and air coarsening.

How processing builds structure

Each process step contributes. Homogenisation creates small fat globules covered with protein. Ageing crystallises fat and lets emulsifiers displace protein, preparing the globules for partial coalescence. In the freezer, rapid nucleation and scraping produce many small ice crystals, metered air is dispersed into fine cells, and shear causes partial coalescence of fat at the air interfaces. Hardening grows the ice crystals, and storage and distribution, if temperature fluctuates, coarsen ice and air. The degree of fat destabilisation is measured by the proportion of fat that is no longer in individual globules (for example by particle sizing after dilution or by solvent-extractable fat), and correlates with meltdown resistance and shape retention.

Understanding this structure explains defects: too little fat destabilisation gives wet, fast-melting ice cream; too much gives buttery particles; large ice crystals give iciness; collapsed air cells give shrinkage. It also explains why fat-reduced and sugar-reduced ice creams are difficult: removing fat removes the stabilising network, and removing sugar changes freezing point and the amount of ice.

Remember

9. Kulfi, frozen yoghurt, sherbet and frozen confections

Kulfi

Kulfi is the traditional frozen dairy dessert of the Indian subcontinent. Milk is concentrated by prolonged boiling, often to about half or less of its original volume, which develops a cooked, caramelised flavour; sugar is added and often nuts, cardamom, saffron or other flavourings. The mix is filled into conical moulds and frozen quiescently, without agitation or whipping, so kulfi has almost no overrun and is dense, chewy and slow-melting, with larger ice crystals than ice cream. Industrial kulfi uses evaporated or recombined milk concentrates, sometimes with khoa, and controlled heating for flavour; mixes may be partly frozen in a freezer with low air before moulding. Indian standards treat kulfi with similar minimum composition to ice cream; vegetable-fat versions must be labelled accordingly.

Frozen yoghurt, sherbet, sorbet and water ice

Frozen yoghurt is made by blending a frozen dessert mix with yoghurt or by culturing part or all of the mix, then freezing it in an ice cream freezer. It has a mildly acid flavour; products claiming live cultures must keep viable organisms through frozen storage, which most yoghurt cultures survive reasonably well, and some jurisdictions or trade bodies set minimum counts or acidity. Heat-treated versions have no live cultures. Sherbet contains a little milk fat and milk solids with a high sugar content and fruit acid, giving a tart, fruity product with modest overrun. Sorbet and water ice contain no milk; they are fruit or flavoured sugar syrups with stabiliser, frozen with or without aeration. Because they lack fat and protein, their structure depends on sugar composition and stabilisers.

Novelties and other frozen confections

Frozen confections include stick bars moulded in brine or direct-expansion moulding machines, extruded shapes, cones with chocolate-coated wafers protected by a fat barrier against moisture migration, sandwiches, and ice cream coated in chocolate or compound coatings (enrobed or dipped). Mellorine (in the United States) and Indian 'frozen dessert' use vegetable fat. Gelato, the Italian style, generally has lower fat and lower overrun than standard ice cream, is served warmer and often contains more milk than cream, though composition is not defined uniformly. Soft-serve uses lower-fat mix drawn fresh at a warmer temperature. Each format brings its own process engineering, but the mix chemistry and structural principles are the same.

Remember

10. Reduced-fat and reduced-sugar ice cream

Reducing fat

Fat contributes richness, flavour release, smoothness, air stability through partial coalescence, and slow melting. Removing it gives a product that tends to be icy, coarse, crumbly or gummy, melts fast and tastes thin. Reduced-fat formulations compensate by raising MSNF and protein (limited by lactose sandiness, which lactase treatment of the milk can address), using fat replacers, adding more stabiliser, and choosing emulsifiers and processing that maximise the effect of the fat that remains. Fat replacers are protein-based (microparticulated whey protein, which forms tiny particles perceived as creamy), carbohydrate-based (maltodextrins, polydextrose, inulin, modified starches, fibres) or fat-based mimetics. Low-temperature extrusion helps by producing smaller ice crystals. Legal terms such as 'reduced fat', 'light' and 'low fat' are defined by percentage reduction against a reference or by grams per serving, and differ between jurisdictions.

Reducing sugar

Sugar reduction is harder than it looks, because sucrose provides not only sweetness but bulk solids and freezing-point depression. Replacing it with a high-intensity sweetener restores sweetness but leaves a product with more ice and a harder texture at storage temperature, and less body. Formulators therefore combine high-intensity sweeteners with bulking agents that depress the freezing point: polyols such as sorbitol, maltitol and erythritol (which can have laxative effects at high intakes, a reason for labelling limits in some countries), soluble fibres such as inulin and polydextrose, and lactose hydrolysis, which raises sweetness and freezing-point depression from the milk's own lactose. Allulose and other rare sugars are used where permitted. Every substitution changes freezing point, sweetness, viscosity and flavour, so the full set of calculations and sensory tests must be redone.

Remember

11. Defects and their causes

Flavour defects

Ice cream defects are classified by flavour, body and texture, melting quality, colour and package. Flavour defects include lack of flavour or too much flavour; unnatural or harsh flavouring; too little or too much sweetness; cooked flavour from excessive heat treatment; oxidised (cardboard or metallic) flavour from fat oxidation catalysed by copper or light, especially in mixes using old powder or butter; rancid flavour from lipolysis in raw ingredients; stale or storage flavours from old powders or long storage; salty flavour from too much MSNF or whey; acid or sour flavour from microbial growth in mix before freezing; and absorbed odours in storage.

Body and texture defects

Body defects describe the overall consistency. A crumbly body breaks apart easily; causes include low total solids, too little stabiliser, high overrun and very large air cells. A gummy or pasty body comes from too much stabiliser or total solids. A weak body lacks resistance and is caused by low solids, too little stabiliser or high overrun. A soggy body is heavy and wet, from too low overrun and too much sugar. Texture defects describe the fine structure. Coarse or icy texture results from large ice crystals: slow freezing or hardening, heat shock, too little stabiliser, low total solids, or a too-warm draw temperature. Sandy texture is caused by lactose crystals, which do not melt readily in the mouth: too much MSNF, heat shock and long storage are the usual causes. Buttery texture, with perceptible fat particles, comes from excessive fat destabilisation: too much emulsifier, too high fat, inadequate homogenisation or too long or warm freezing. Fluffy or snowy texture comes from too much overrun with large air cells.

Meltdown, shrinkage and colour

Melting defects include a product that does not melt (excessive stabiliser or fat destabilisation), wheying off (serum separation during melting, from stabiliser incompatibility or protein destabilisation, corrected with carrageenan), a curdy meltdown (protein destabilisation from high acidity, salt imbalance or overheating), and foamy melt. Shrinkage is a loss of volume in packages during storage: the product pulls away from the container walls. It is associated with high overrun, small air cells that coalesce, temperature fluctuations, pressure changes during transport (such as by air), and certain protein states. Colour defects include unnatural or uneven colour, and a dull grey appearance from too little flavour or colour. Microbiological defects arise from post-pasteurisation contamination, inclusions or poor cleaning of freezers and fillers, and are the most serious because Listeria monocytogenes can survive in frozen products and has caused outbreaks linked to ice cream; environmental monitoring and hygienic design of freezers and ingredient feeders are therefore critical.

Quality control and judging

Plant quality control of ice cream covers composition (fat and total solids of mix, often by rapid methods), overrun by weighing filled cups, draw and hardening temperatures, package weight, meltdown tests (the rate and manner in which a sample melts on a screen at a set temperature), and microbiological tests of mix and product, typically for total counts, coliforms or Enterobacteriaceae and pathogens. Sensory evaluation uses trained panels or official scorecards with separate scores for flavour, body and texture, melting quality, colour and package, and lists of named defects. In student judging, samples are tempered to a standard serving temperature, examined for appearance and colour, tasted for flavour, pressed against the palate for body and texture, and watched as they melt. Shelf-life studies hold products under realistic and abusive temperature cycles to measure ice crystal growth, sandiness and shrinkage, which are the factors that limit the shelf life of a frozen dessert far more than microbial spoilage.

Remember

What the exams ask

How it is used, across a career

As a student

A student uses this subject to calculate mixes and overrun, explain why ice cream is aged and why emulsifiers destabilise fat, and diagnose sandy, icy or buttery samples in judging practicals. It supports AICE Dairy Chemistry Unit 8 questions and the frozen-dessert part of plant training.

Five years in

An ice cream production or quality officer five years in formulates mixes to cost and specification, sets homogenisation, ageing and draw temperatures, controls overrun at the filler, manages hardening and cold stores, and investigates complaints of iciness, shrinkage or sandiness. This subject provides the calculations and the structure-based reasoning for those decisions.

Twenty-five years in

A plant head or category director decides between batch and continuous freezing, investment in low-temperature extrusion or hardening capacity, reformulation for fat and sugar reduction, and distribution strategies that protect the cold chain. They answer for legal compliance (composition, weight per volume, labelling) and food safety, where Listeria control in freezers is critical.

PhD, twenty-five years in

A professor or research director works on ice recrystallisation, glass transitions, air-cell stability, fat destabilisation, novel stabilisers and fat and sugar replacers. They teach AICE Dairy Chemistry and set questions on ice cream structure and defects, and advise industry and regulators on formulation and standards.

Written from

This manual does not yet give: current FSSAI, EU member-state and other national compositional limits for ice cream, kulfi and frozen desserts; detailed freezing-point calculation tables; freezer and hardening-tunnel engineering design; coating and moulding technology for novelties in detail; and permitted levels of stabilisers, emulsifiers, sweeteners and colours, which differ by country. Temperatures, compositions and overrun ranges are representative values, not recipes.

Original practice questions written to the syllabus and pattern of the exams named in each question's examTags. They are not past papers and do not reproduce any board's questions.

Practise it, and prove it

These notes are free to read here, with no account.

What the Laisha app adds:

Free for ten days, then a subscription. We would rather write that here than have you find it later.

Open Laisha →