LAISHA
Open Laisha

Australasian Veterinary Examination, formerly the National Veterinary Examination Animal Welfare, Ethics & Veterinary Jurisprudence: practice questions

Australasian Veterinary Examination (AVE), formerly the National Veterinary Examination (NVE) · Australia / New Zealand · Australasian Veterinary Boards Council (AVBC)

Original practice questions written to the published syllabus · not past papers
7worked here, free
22written to this exam in this subject
11syllabus units

What this subject covers

The veterinarian in court and in law: expert evidence, vetero-legal post-mortems, frauds and insurance, offences against animals, codes of conduct and certification.

In the exams: RCVS SME Code of Professional Conduct paper (60 MCQs); SAVC law and ethics 15; China law and ethics 20; Korea veterinary law and animal husbandry 20; Nepal NLEV ethics and jurisprudence 4; RPSC (IVC Act 1984)

Where the 22 questions fall

How our questions for Australasian Veterinary Examination, formerly the National Veterinary Examination spread across the units of Animal Welfare, Ethics & Veterinary Jurisprudence. Difficulty: 4 easy, 10 medium, 8 hard.

Code of conduct and professional ethics5
Principles of veterinary certification4
Judicial procedure2
The veterinarian as expert witness2
Species identification2
Frauds in the livestock trade2
The vetero-legal post-mortem1
Estimating time since death1
Animal insurance1
Offences against animals1
Animal welfare law1

7 practice questions, worked

Choose an answer, then open the working. Each explanation says why the right answer is right and why the others are not.

1 · Judicial procedure · easy

An owner sues a veterinarian in a civil court, alleging that negligent surgery killed her dog. What standard of proof must the owner meet?

  1. On the balance of probabilities: that negligence was more likely than not
  2. Beyond reasonable doubt, the same standard that applies to cruelty prosecutions
  3. Scientific certainty, which requires a post-mortem showing the exact surgical error
  4. A prima facie case only, after which the veterinarian must prove innocence
Answer and working

A. On the balance of probabilities: that negligence was more likely than not

Civil claims are decided on the balance of probabilities. Proof beyond reasonable doubt is the criminal standard, used when the state prosecutes cruelty; borrowing it for a negligence claim is the commonest confusion. Courts never demand scientific certainty.

Further reading: Standard texts on civil and criminal procedure in common-law systems

2 · Species identification · medium

On a horse's upper corner incisor, Galvayne's groove extends about halfway down the tooth from the gum. What age does the traditional description suggest?

  1. About 10 years
  2. About 20 years
  3. About 15 years
  4. About 30 years
Answer and working

C. About 15 years

Galvayne's groove traditionally appears at the gum at about 10 years, reaches halfway at about 15, reaches the table at about 20 and has grown out by about 30. It is absent or irregular in many horses, so it should only support other dental signs.

Further reading: Standard equine dentistry texts

3 · Animal insurance · medium

An insured horse has a surgical colic, the owner cannot afford surgery, the horse is in severe pain, and the insurer's emergency line cannot be reached. What should the veterinarian do?

  1. Keep the horse alive on analgesia until the insurer can be reached during office hours
  2. Euthanase on humane grounds, record why, and notify the insurer as soon as possible
  3. Refuse to euthanase, because an insured horse may never be euthanased without consent
  4. Euthanase, but record the cause as a fracture so that the claim is more likely to succeed
Answer and working

B. Euthanase on humane grounds, record why, and notify the insurer as soon as possible

Policies generally allow euthanasia without prior insurer agreement when immediate euthanasia is needed on humane grounds; the veterinarian must then record and certify the justification. Prolonging severe suffering is a welfare failure, and falsifying the cause is fraud.

Further reading: BEVA guidance on euthanasia of insured horses

4 · Offences against animals · hard

You are asked by an inspector to examine twelve thin ponies in a neglect case. Which record will be most useful to the court?

  1. Identity, body condition score, injuries, feet, parasites and the environment, photographed with a scale
  2. A short note that the ponies looked thin and unhappy, so that the report remains easy to read
  3. Only the post-mortem findings of any pony that dies, since live findings are not admissible
  4. The owner's explanation of events, written up as your own conclusion on cause and duration
Answer and working

A. Identity, body condition score, injuries, feet, parasites and the environment, photographed with a scale

Neglect is proved by detailed, objective, individual records: identity, body condition, weight, feet, coat, parasites, injuries, behaviour and the conditions of food, water and shelter, with dated photographs including a scale. Live findings are admissible. The owner's account should be recorded as their account, not adopted as your opinion.

Further reading: Munro and Munro, Animal Abuse and Unlawful Killing

5 · Code of conduct and professional ethics · medium

An owner signs a consent form for a cruciate repair on her dog but is not told the likely cost, which turns out to be three times her expectation. Was her consent informed?

  1. No, because cost is part of the information a client needs for informed consent
  2. Yes, because a signed consent form is conclusive proof that consent was informed
  3. Yes, because fees are a business matter and play no part in consent at all
  4. No, because consent for surgery can be given only by the referring veterinarian
Answer and working

A. No, because cost is part of the information a client needs for informed consent

Informed consent covers the procedure, its risks and alternatives, and its likely cost; veterinary codes such as the RCVS's explicitly include fee estimates. A signature without the necessary information does not make consent informed.

Further reading: RCVS Code of Professional Conduct, supporting guidance on communication and consent

6 · Code of conduct and professional ethics · medium

An assistant veterinarian employed by a practice negligently injures a client's horse during a routine procedure. Who is usually liable to the client?

  1. The employer, vicariously, as well as the assistant who was negligent
  2. Only the assistant, because employers are never liable for employees
  3. Only the client, because owners accept all risks of routine procedures
  4. Only the veterinary regulator, which licensed the assistant to practise
Answer and working

A. The employer, vicariously, as well as the assistant who was negligent

An employer is usually vicariously liable for negligence of employees acting in the course of employment, which is one reason practices carry professional indemnity insurance. Owners do not accept the risk of negligent treatment.

Further reading: Law of tort, standard texts

7 · Animal welfare law · medium

What is the key legal advantage of a 'duty of care' welfare statute over an older anti-cruelty statute?

  1. Penalties apply only after an animal has died, which makes cases easier to prove
  2. Action can be taken before an animal suffers, when its needs are not being met
  3. It removes the need for veterinary evidence in every welfare prosecution
  4. It applies only to farm animals, leaving pets to the older cruelty laws
Answer and working

B. Action can be taken before an animal suffers, when its needs are not being met

Anti-cruelty statutes generally require proof that suffering was caused. A positive duty to meet needs lets inspectors and courts intervene earlier, for example where shelter or diet is inadequate but serious suffering has not yet occurred. Both models apply to companion and farm animals.

Further reading: Animal Welfare Act 2006 (England and Wales); comparative welfare law texts

Ten here, 22 in the app. The Laisha app has every practice question we have written to Australasian Veterinary Examination, formerly the National Veterinary Examination in this subject, marked as you go, with timed papers, a jump-to-unanswered list and a certificate when you pass at 70 per cent.

Free for ten days, then one subscription of US$10 a month. We would rather say so here than have you find it later.

Practise the full set in Laisha →

Read the subject

Animal Welfare, Ethics & Veterinary JurisprudenceThe full study manual, free Australasian Veterinary Examination, formerly the National Veterinary ExaminationFormat, sections and how it has changed

More Australasian Veterinary Examination, formerly the National Veterinary Examination practice

Companion Animal Practice: Breeding, Management, Nutrition and Health CareEquine Medicine, Surgery & PracticeLivestock Farm PracticesVeterinary Clinical Practice (Veterinary Clinical Complex)Animal Behaviour, Ethology & Welfare ScienceExotic, Pocket Pet, Pet Bird & Reptile MedicineEmergency & Critical Care, Fluid Therapy and EuthanasiaCommunication, Professionalism, Practice Management & WellbeingAquatic Animal Diseases, Health Care & ManagementVeterinary Clinical Medicine II: Metabolic, Production and Deficiency DiseasesPreventive Veterinary Medicine II: Viral and Parasitic DiseasesVeterinary Pharmacy, Prescribing Law & Medicines RegulationVeterinary ObstetricsFood-Animal Production Medicine & Herd HealthDiagnostic Imaging: Radiology and UltrasonographyGeneral Veterinary MicrobiologySystematic Veterinary VirologyGeneral Veterinary PathologyVeterinary Andrology & Assisted Reproductive TechniquesVeterinary Physiology I: Body Fluids, Blood, Circulation, Respiration and ExcretionClinical, Diagnostic & Immuno-ParasitologyAvian PathologyVeterinary Clinical Biochemistry & Laboratory DiagnosisSystematic Veterinary Bacteriology & Mycology

Animal Welfare, Ethics & Veterinary Jurisprudence for other exams

ICAR AICE-JRF/SRF · IndiaRCVS Statutory Membership Examination · UKRPSC Veterinary Officer · IndiaSAVC Registration Examination · South Africa

Ask Laisha about this

Opens Laisha's chat with your question ready to send. Sign in or start free.