LAISHA
Open Laisha

The Potato Famine: When One Crop Failed | Late Blight, Ireland 1845 and Lessons for Farmers

Video · · 47 min 32 s

In the late summer of 1845 a microscopic water mould, Phytophthora infestans, reached Ireland's potato fields. In the years that followed, about one million people died and more than a million emigrated; the island still has fewer people than in 1841. This film tells the story from the potato's origins in the Andes to the blight's arrival from America, the famine years, the emigrant ships and the help that came from unexpected places, and asks why Ireland suffered so much more than the rest of Europe. Then it turns to today: other one-crop failures (coffee rust in Ceylon, Panama disease of bananas, the 1970 US corn blight), why late blight is still a costly potato and tomato disease, and what farmers do now: weather-based warnings (Smith Period, Hutton Criteria), scouting, hygiene, resistant varieties and diversity. Where historians disagree (food exports, the Doolough death toll, where the pathogen came from) the film says so.

Late blight of potato and tomato →

Subscribe on YouTube

Transcript

Late summer, eighteen forty-five.

A potato field on the edge of Dublin. The plants look healthy one week.

A few days later the leaves have dark, wet blotches, and the field smells of rot.

Under the soil, the tubers are turning brown.

That same autumn, the same thing was happening across much of northern Europe. Belgium, the Netherlands, parts of Germany, the south of England.

But in one country, Ireland, a huge share of the people ate almost nothing else.

Over the next seven years, about one million people in Ireland died, and more than a million left. The population of the island has never fully recovered.

Even today, it is smaller than it was in eighteen forty-one.

The cause was a microscopic organism that drifts on the wind and loves wet weather. Its name means, quite literally, plant destroyer.

And it has never gone away.

Farmers on every continent still fight it, every single season.

So this is a story about a famine. But it is also a story about a crop, and about a very old farming mistake: putting everything on one plant, one variety, one bet.

We'll go to the Andes, where the potato began, to the fields and ships of the eighteen forties, and to the laboratories that finally named the killer.

And we'll end in today's potato fields, from Kenya to Scotland, where farmers now scout for the same enemy with weather data and new varieties.

We're your guides, from Laisha.

Let's start where the potato starts.

High in the mountains of South America.

Picture the shore of Lake Titicaca, nearly four kilometres above sea level, on the border of Peru and Bolivia. Cold nights, strong sun, thin air. Not the place you'd expect one of the world's great food crops to begin.

And yet that's roughly where it did.

A large genetic study, published in two thousand and five, concluded that the cultivated potato was domesticated once, in the Andes of southern Peru, from wild relatives that still grow there. At least seven thousand years ago.

Seven thousand years. So the potato is older as a crop than most of the cities we've heard of.

Much older. And here's the part that matters for our story.

Andean farmers never grew just one potato.

They grew dozens in one field.

Yellow, purple, red, long, knobbly, bitter, sweet.

Some for boiling, some that survive frost, some that store for years. Store for years? A potato?

Once it's been turned into chuño. Farmers spread small potatoes out on the high ground, let them freeze at night, thaw in the sun, and then tread on them to squeeze out the water. What's left is light, dry, and keeps for a very long time. It's a famine food, made on purpose, before the famine comes.

That's a whole insurance system. Many varieties in the ground, and a dried store in the house.

Exactly.

The International Potato Center in Lima now keeps a genebank with more than five thousand cultivated potato samples, and nearly four thousand eight hundred of them are traditional varieties from eighteen countries.

That's the diversity the Andes built.

And it's still in farmers' fields, not only in a freezer. Near Pisac, in Peru, six Quechua communities set up what they call the Potato Park in nineteen ninety-eight.

They grow and look after more than thirteen hundred varieties there. Hold that picture in your mind. Thirteen hundred varieties in one valley.

Because when the potato crossed the ocean, almost all of that diversity stayed behind.

So how did it cross?

The usual story is that Sir Walter Raleigh brought it to Ireland.

It's a lovely story, and historians say it's a legend.

The earliest known claim dates from more than a century later.

The first written record of potatoes in Europe is a shipment from the Canary Islands to Antwerp, in November fifteen sixty-seven.

A few years later, a hospital in Seville was buying them.

So the potato arrives through Spain, quietly.

And then it spreads.

Slowly at first.

Many Europeans were suspicious of a plant that grew underground and was related to nightshade. But over the seventeen hundreds, governments and reformers pushed it hard.

In France, the pharmacist Antoine Parmentier became its champion.

Across Germany, Belgium, Poland and Russia, it became a field crop.

Why? What made it so attractive?

Yield. An acre of potatoes feeds far more people than an acre of grain.

It grows in poor, wet soil.

It doesn't need milling.

And because it grows underground, an army marching through can't easily burn it. Which brings us to the country where that advantage went further than anywhere else.

Ireland, around eighteen forty. A wet, mild island on the edge of the Atlantic.

The potato loves it here.

And by now, the poorest part of the population lives on it almost entirely.

How poor are we talking about?

The census of eighteen forty-one counted just over eight million people. Historians now think the real number may have been closer to eight point four million.

And the economic historian Cormac Ó Gráda describes the bottom third or so of the population as almost wholly dependent on the potato.

And when you say dependent, how many potatoes are we talking about, for one person?

Estimates vary. Ó Gráda gives about four to five kilos a day for an adult man. Other historians go as high as six kilos, about fourteen pounds. Every day. With some buttermilk, if the family was lucky.

Six kilos a day. That's a whole sack in a week, for one person.

And it actually worked, nutritionally.

Potatoes and milk together give a surprising amount of what the body needs.

Writers of the time, Adam Smith among them, remarked on how strong the Irish labourers in London were. The problem wasn't the diet. It was what would happen if it disappeared.

Let's talk about how these families farmed. Because the system mattered.

Most of the poorest families didn't own land. Many rented a tiny patch, sometimes just for one season, a system called conacre, and paid for it with labour or cash. On that patch they grew potatoes in ridges called lazy beds.

Lazy beds.

That name always sounds unfair.

It is unfair. It's hard work. You lay the seed potatoes on the grass, cut the turf on each side, and fold it over them, so you get a raised bed with a drainage ditch in between.

It works on wet, thin, rocky ground where a plough is useless. You can still see the old ridges on hillsides in the west of Ireland and in Scotland today.

Those ridges on the hills, in places where nobody lives now.

Exactly.

And here's the other piece.

Over time, the very poor came to rely on a few heavy-yielding varieties. Above all, one called the Lumper.

The Lumper.

What was special about it? It yielded heavily on poor soil. By most accounts it wasn't the best-tasting potato.

But it filled the most bellies per patch, and so the poorest grew it. That meant millions of plants with very little genetic difference between them.

And that's the key point for farmers watching this. A potato isn't grown from seed in the usual way. You plant a piece of last year's tuber.

So every Lumper plant is essentially a clone of every other Lumper plant.

Right. If a disease can beat one of them, it can beat all of them.

In the Andes, a field might hold dozens of varieties.

In much of Ireland, a field held one.

And there was another weak spot. The old crop ran out each summer before the new one was ready.

People called those weeks the hungry months.

So even in a normal year, the margin was thin. One failed harvest, and the poorest had nothing to fall back on.

Then, in the summer of eighteen forty-five,

something arrived from across the ocean.

The disease didn't start in Ireland.

It was first seen on the east coast of the United States, around Philadelphia and New York, in eighteen forty-three.

Farmers there watched potato fields collapse in a matter of days.

And from America to Europe?

Most likely on ships, in infected seed potatoes.

Europe at the time was importing potatoes from the Americas, including new seed varieties.

By June eighteen forty-five, the blight was in Flanders, in Belgium.

Some researchers think it was already there in eighteen forty-four.

Then it moves fast. In August, a gardening journal in London reports a blight of unusual character on the Isle of Wight. Within weeks it's in the Netherlands, France, Germany, southern England.

And Ireland?

On the twentieth of August, the curator of the Botanic Gardens at Glasnevin, in Dublin, a Scottish gardener named David Moore, notes it in the garden's potatoes.

It's the first verified record of the disease in Ireland.

A botanist noticing it in a garden.

That's scouting, in a way.

It is. Then, on the thirteenth of September, the same London journal, the Gardeners' Chronicle, prints a famous line.

We stop the press, with very great regret, to announce that the potato murrain has unequivocally declared itself in Ireland.

Murrain. That's an old word for a plague on crops or animals.

And it was the right word.

What did people actually see?

Pale, water-soaked spots on the leaves that turned dark brown and spread. In damp mornings, a fine white fuzz on the underside.

Black streaks on the stems. Then the whole plant collapsing.

That matches what we'd see in a blighted field today.

And the tubers?

The tubers were the cruel part. Some potatoes looked fine at harvest and rotted later in the pit, turning into a stinking, reddish-brown mush.

Families dug what seemed like a good crop, stored it, and came back weeks later to find it gone.

So what did people try?

Everything. Drying the potatoes in kilns, salting them, storing them in different ways.

Some experts blamed wet weather, or static electricity, or the guano fertiliser being imported at the time. A scientific commission was sent from London to Ireland.

Its advice didn't stop the rot.

Because nobody yet knew what the disease actually was.

Exactly. In eighteen forty-five, the blight destroyed roughly a third of Ireland's potato crop. A terrible year, but survivable for many.

People ate what they could save, sold what they had, and hoped next year would be better.

And the next year, they planted again.

Mostly the same potatoes. In the same kind of fields.

Before we see what happened, let's stop and meet the culprit. Because the more you understand it, the more the history makes sense.

Its name is Phytophthora infestans.

Phytophthora comes from Greek, and it means plant destroyer.

And it's a fungus?

It looks like one, and for a century everyone called it one. But it isn't. It belongs to a group called oomycetes, or water moulds. Their closest relatives are certain algae, not mushrooms.

That matters, because many fungicides that work on true fungi don't work on it.

Water mould. So water is part of the story.

Water is the whole story. On a wet leaf, the mould grows inside the plant tissue.

Then it pushes tiny branched stalks out through the leaf's pores,

and on them it makes spore sacs, called sporangia.

That's the white fuzz on the underside of a leaf.

And the wind carries those?

Wind and rain splash.

A spore sac that lands on a wet leaf, in cool weather, can release swimming spores that infect the leaf in a few hours.

In warm, wet weather, a new lesion can be making fresh spores within about five days.

Each cycle multiplies the last.

So it's not a slow disease.

Not at all.

In the right weather, a field can go from a few spots to brown and dead in a week or two.

And the summer of eighteen forty-five in northern Europe was cool and damp.

Ideal. And the tubers?

Rain washes spores down into the soil, where they infect the potatoes.

Infected tubers can rot in store.

And an infected tuber that survives to be planted next spring can carry the disease into the new crop.

So the seed potato is a carrier. That's why it could cross an ocean.

Exactly.

Now, in the eighteen forties, scientists argued fiercely about cause and effect.

Most experts believed the plant rotted first, from wet weather or bad soil, and that the mould just grew on dead tissue.

But not everyone.

Not everyone.

An English clergyman and mycologist, Miles Joseph Berkeley, argued in eighteen forty-six that the mould was the cause, not the result.

He was largely right, and he was in the minority.

How long did it take to prove him right?

Years. The German botanist Anton de Bary showed in eighteen sixty-one how the mould grows through potato tissue, and with his later infection experiments he settled the question.

In eighteen seventy-six he gave it the name we still use,

Phytophthora infestans.

So the famine is also the moment a whole science gets going.

That's how the American Phytopathological Society puts it. Late blight marks the beginning of plant pathology as a science.

Now, there's a modern twist to this. We actually know which strain caused the famine.

Yes, and it's a wonderful piece of detective work.

Old museum herbarium sheets, dried blighted potato leaves from the eighteen forties onward, still hold the pathogen's DNA.

In two thousand and thirteen, a team sequenced it. They found the nineteenth-century epidemics were caused by one particular lineage, which they called HERB one.

And it's still around?

It seems not. In the twentieth century, a different lineage called US one took over worldwide.

Another team, working on the same kind of old samples, calls the famine lineage FAM one.

They agree it was distinct from today's strains, but they describe the relationship with US one a little differently.

And where did the pathogen originally come from?

That's still debated.

One group of researchers argues for central Mexico, where the pathogen has a sexual population and close wild relatives.

Others have argued for the Andes.

Both cases have real evidence, so we'll leave it open.

Either way, it came from the Americas, like the potato itself. The crop crossed the ocean without its enemy.

Then, three centuries later, the enemy caught up.

Back to Ireland.

In the autumn of eighteen forty-five, Britain was governed by the Conservative prime minister Sir Robert Peel.

Ireland was then part of the United Kingdom, ruled from London.

What did his government do?

Peel acted quickly, in one way. In the autumn of eighteen forty-five, his government secretly ordered about a hundred thousand pounds' worth of Indian corn,

maize, from America, through a London bank. The idea was to sell it cheaply and keep food prices down.

Maize. To people who'd never cooked it.

Right. It was hard, needed long cooking, and people had little idea how to prepare it. People nicknamed it Peel's brimstone.

But it did help, in that first hungry season.

And Peel also used the crisis politically.

He did. He pushed through the repeal of the Corn Laws, which had kept grain prices high to protect landowners.

The repeal passed in June eighteen forty-six. It split his own party, and within days his government fell.

A Whig government under Lord John Russell took over.

And then came the summer of eighteen forty-six.

And then came eighteen forty-six.

This time the blight struck early and almost everywhere. Ó Gráda's figures show the harvest down by close to ninety percent. Witnesses described green fields in July that were black by August.

Ninety percent. For families who ate nothing else.

The new government believed strongly that the state should not interfere with markets.

The key official in charge of relief was Charles Trevelyan, at the Treasury.

He's become, fairly or not, the face of that policy.

So what was the relief?

First, public works.

People were paid to build roads, many of them leading nowhere, so they could buy food.

By March eighteen forty-seven, about seven hundred thousand people were on the works. Roughly one in every twelve people in Ireland.

Breaking stones in winter, while starving.

Yes. The winter of eighteen forty-six to forty-seven was unusually harsh.

Wages were low and often late, and food prices had soared. People collapsed on the works.

That winter is remembered as Black Forty-Seven.

Did anything work better?

Soup kitchens did. Quaker volunteers, the Society of Friends, had set them up early.

Then, in February eighteen forty-seven, a law usually called the Soup Kitchen Act moved the government to feeding people directly.

By the summer, about three million people a day were getting rations.

Three million a day. So the state could feed people when it chose to.

That's the point many historians make. But the kitchens were meant to be temporary, and they were wound down by the end of September.

After that, the burden was shifted to local taxes and to the workhouses.

And there's a law from that year that farmers listening will find chilling.

The Gregory clause, passed in June eighteen forty-seven.

Anyone holding more than a quarter of an acre of land could not get public relief. So to feed their children, families had to give up their land.

Give up the land, to get the soup.

And once you leave the land, you can't grow next year's crop.

Exactly. Evictions rose sharply in the years that followed. In some places, landlords cleared whole villages.

I want to ask the question a lot of people ask. Was food leaving Ireland while people starved?

Yes, food kept leaving, and this is one of the most argued points in the whole history.

The historian Christine Kinealy found that thousands of ships carried food from Ireland to Britain in eighteen forty-seven, and she argues the official figures undercount it.

And the other side?

Other historians, Ó Gráda among them, point out that from eighteen forty-seven, Ireland imported far more grain, mostly maize, than it exported.

And they stress the deadly gap in the winter of eighteen forty-six, before those imports arrived. The deeper problem was that the poorest had no money to buy any food at all.

So food on the quays, and people too poor to buy it. That's the heart of it. In eighteen forty-seven itself, the blight was actually mild.

But hardly anyone had planted, because they had eaten their seed potatoes. Ó Gráda's figures put the area planted that year at a fraction of normal.

The famine is eating next year's harvest.

Yes.

And the newspapers in London did send artists.

In early eighteen forty-seven, the Illustrated London News printed drawings by James Mahony from Skibbereen in County Cork. Families in bare cabins. A funeral in an empty street.

Then the blight came back in eighteen forty-eight, and ruined most of that harvest too. The famine lasted not one year, but years.

One story from that time stays with people.

In March eighteen forty-nine, hungry people in Louisburgh, County Mayo, were told to report to officials at a hunting lodge about nineteen kilometres away, through the Doolough valley, to keep their relief.

They walked there in bitter weather.

And how many died on that road?

Nobody knows for certain. A newspaper at the time reported seven bodies found by the roadside.

Local tradition says many more, possibly hundreds.

Today there's a simple stone cross by the lake, and every year people walk that road in memory.

By eighteen fifty-two, the best estimate is that about one million people had died, roughly one in eight of the population. Most from hunger-related diseases, like typhus and dysentery, rather than starvation alone.

And more than a million had already left. Let's follow them.

For many families, the only escape was the sea. Some landlords paid passage for their tenants to clear their estates.

Others went with money sent home by relatives who had left before.

Where did they go?

Liverpool first, for many. It was the great port. Then on to North America: New York, Boston, Philadelphia, and Canada, because passage to British North America was often cheaper.

And these were the coffin ships.

That's the name that stuck. Many were cargo ships, timber ships coming back empty from Canada, packed with passengers.

Little food, little water, no doctors.

People were already weak and sick when they boarded.

And in eighteen forty-seven, it got worst of all. It did.

Parks Canada, which now runs the site, says that in eighteen forty-seven more than a hundred thousand immigrants sailed for Quebec.

Over five thousand died at sea.

Ships were held at a quarantine island in the Saint Lawrence river called Grosse Île.

Grosse Île.

Five thousand, four hundred and twenty-four people were buried there that year. Many of them children.

Today it's a national historic site, with a large Celtic cross on the island's height.

And in America, the people who survived the crossing?

They often arrived penniless, ill, and unwelcome.

They crowded into the poorest parts of Boston and New York.

And they rebuilt, slowly.

Within a few generations, Irish Americans were in every part of public life. That's why so many American cities have famine memorials now.

There's one emigration story that isn't about America at all. You mean the orphan girls.

Yes. Between eighteen forty-eight and eighteen fifty, a scheme named after the British colonial secretary, Earl Grey, sent four thousand one hundred and fourteen teenage girls from Irish workhouses to Australia.

Sydney, Adelaide, and Port Phillip, which is now Melbourne.

Girls, on their own, to the other side of the world.

Most of those landing in Sydney were housed for a while at the Hyde Park Barracks.

Since nineteen ninety-nine, there's been a memorial to them there, the Australian Monument to the Great Irish Famine.

And there's another kind of story, of help that came from people who had very little themselves.

The Choctaw Nation.

Yes. In March eighteen forty-seven, members of the Choctaw Nation, in what is now Oklahoma, gave one hundred and seventy dollars for Irish famine relief.

Only about sixteen years earlier, they themselves had been forced off their homelands on the long march west that's remembered as the Trail of Tears.

And the Irish remember it. They do. In twenty seventeen, a sculpture called Kindred Spirits was dedicated in Midleton, County Cork.

Nine tall steel feathers, curved into the shape of an empty bowl.

And the Ottoman Sultan, who's said to have sent ships of food?

That one needs care. That Sultan Abdülmecid gave one thousand pounds in eighteen forty-seven is reasonably well documented. The famous details, that he offered ten times more and was asked to cut it, or that his ships sailed secretly into Drogheda, aren't supported by records we could find.

So, a real gift, wrapped in a legend.

Gifts came from many places, then. Quakers in Ireland, Britain and America, churches,

and ordinary people in many countries. But a gift can't replace a harvest.

And the leaving didn't stop when the famine ended.

Within a decade or so, about two million people had left Ireland.

Which raises a question. The blight was all over Europe.

Why was Ireland hit so much harder than everyone else?

It's a fair question, and it's often forgotten that the blight was a European disaster.

The years from eighteen forty-five to eighteen forty-eight are sometimes called the last great subsistence crisis in western Europe. So who else suffered?

Historians who compared the regions, in a book called When the Potato Failed, found that deaths in Belgium, the Netherlands and Prussia ran about thirty to forty percent above normal.

In Belgium and in Prussia, the famine killed more than forty thousand people each.

That's a lot of people.

And yet almost nobody has heard of it. Because, in total, the deaths outside Ireland were around a hundred thousand. Ireland's were about ten times that, on one island.

And Scotland?

The Scottish Highlands had a potato famine too, from eighteen forty-six, lasting into the eighteen fifties. Highland crofters depended heavily on the potato, much like western Ireland. But the death toll there was far smaller, because charity relief was organised fast.

Though people still left.

Many left. More than sixteen thousand were helped to emigrate by landlords and charities.

The historian Tom Devine estimates that about a third of the population of the western Highlands left between eighteen forty-one and eighteen sixty-one.

The ruined stone houses are still there. So what made Ireland different? Let's put it plainly.

Historians usually point to a few things together.

First, dependence.

In Belgium or Prussia, poor families also ate rye bread, peas, buckwheat. In Ireland, millions had nothing but the potato. So the same disease hits a diverse diet, and a single-crop diet, very differently.

Exactly. Second, poverty.

People who own nothing can't buy food when prices jump. Third, the blight came back year after year.

And fourth, policy. How fast relief comes, and who it reaches, makes an enormous difference.

Scotland showed that.

Those four together.

One crop, no money, repeated failure, and slow relief.

And you could argue they're all forms of the same thing. Too little diversity. In the field, on the plate, in income, and in the plans for when things go wrong.

Which is exactly why this isn't only history.

Because the potato famine wasn't the last time a whole system bet on one crop.

A short note about laisha.ai, which supports this channel.

Its grow guides are free to read, and the app adds a crop health check:

describe what you see on a plant, and it lists likely causes and what to check.

There is also a crop calendar, pest alerts, and mock tests for agriculture entrance exams.

All of that is one plan, Laisha Smarter, ten US dollars a month after a ten day free trial.

Now, back to the story.

Let's travel a bit.

First stop, Ceylon, the island now called Sri Lanka, in the eighteen sixties. Coffee is king.

Planters have cleared huge areas of hill forest for one crop.

And something arrives.

In eighteen sixty-nine, a rust fungus, Hemileia vastatrix, is spotted on coffee leaves.

Orange powder on the underside, leaves dropping. Over the next fifteen years or so it spreads through the plantations.

Coffee exports collapse.

One account puts the drop at about eighty percent by eighteen eighty-six.

And that's why Sri Lanka is famous for tea, not coffee.

Exactly. The planters switched to tea.

Coffee leaf rust, by the way, is still one of the most important coffee diseases in the world, from Kenya to Central America.

Second stop. Bananas. For the first half of the twentieth century, the world's export banana was one variety, the Gros Michel.

Grown in vast plantations across Central America,

and, like the potato, propagated as clones.

So we know where this is going.

We do. A soil fungus, the cause of Panama disease, spread from farm to farm.

Plantations were abandoned.

By the nineteen fifties and sixties, the export trade had moved to a resistant variety, the Cavendish.

And now the Cavendish has its own problem.

It does.

A newer strain, called Tropical Race Four, was identified in Asia around the early nineteen nineties. It has since spread to Africa and the Middle East, and in twenty nineteen it was confirmed in Colombia.

Once again, a world trade built on one clone.

Third stop. The United States, nineteen seventy.

Maize. This one is almost a laboratory experiment.

Seed companies had found a handy trick for making hybrid maize seed, using a particular type of plant called Texas cytoplasm. It saved a lot of labour. By nineteen seventy, most of the hybrid corn in the US carried it.

And a fungus found the gap. A race of the fungus that causes southern corn leaf blight turned out to be very aggressive on exactly that cytoplasm.

In one summer, it swept the corn belt.

About fifteen percent of the US crop was lost, worth around one billion dollars at the time.

That's a modern, scientific farming system, making the same mistake as the Lumper.

The same mistake, with better records. The seed industry moved away from that cytoplasm within a year or two.

And there's one more example people mention, though the role of the disease is debated.

Bengal, nineteen forty-three.

A fungal disease of rice, brown spot, badly damaged the crop of nineteen forty-two.

Some historians argue it was a major cause of the famine that followed.

Others, like the economist Amartya Sen, stress that people simply lost the means to buy food, during a war.

Somewhere between one and a half and three million people died.

Which sounds a lot like the arguments about Ireland.

It does. A crop disease starts it.

Poverty, prices and policy decide how many die.

So, the pattern.

Uniform crops, a new or changing pathogen, weather that suits it, and nothing to fall back on.

And the potato blight itself?

Is it still a danger, or is it a history-book disease now?

Ask any potato farmer. It never left.

Late blight is still one of the most damaging diseases of potatoes in the world, and of tomatoes too. Wherever summers are cool and wet, it's a weekly worry.

How big is the damage, in money?

Researchers at Wageningen University, in the Netherlands, estimated losses plus control costs of more than one billion euros a year in the developed world alone. Wider estimates for the whole world run to several billion euros a year. The exact figures vary by study, so treat them as a rough scale.

Several billion, every year, from the same organism that caused the famine.

Yes. And the first real weapon against it came, of all places, from a vineyard.

Bordeaux mixture.

Yes. In October eighteen eighty-two, a French botanist, Alexis Millardet, noticed that vines sprayed with a mix of copper sulphate and lime were free of downy mildew. The story goes that the spray was meant to put off grape thieves. He published the method in eighteen eighty-five.

Downy mildew of grapes is another water mould, a cousin of potato blight.

And it worked on potatoes too?

It did, and copper sprays became standard on potatoes for decades.

Then, in the twentieth century, came modern fungicides.

And then the pathogen started to change.

Change how?

Phytophthora has two mating types, called A one and A two. For a long time, outside Mexico, mostly one type was found. From around the nineteen eighties, the second type turned up across Europe and beyond.

When both meet, the pathogen can reproduce sexually. That means new combinations of genes, and tough resting spores that can survive in the soil.

So it can evolve faster.

Much faster. In Europe, a monitoring network called EuroBlight tracks the main lineages by code names. One aggressive lineage, known as Blue thirteen, is resistant to an older group of fungicides. Another, first found in the Netherlands in twenty twenty-two, resists a newer group.

It was found in Britain in twenty twenty-four.

And on the other side of the Atlantic?

In two thousand and nine, the northeast of the United States had a big late blight epidemic. A study traced much of it to infected tomato plants sold at large garden centres, from Pennsylvania to Maine.

Home gardeners planted them, and the spores spread to farms.

That's the seed potato story again, just with tomato plants.

Exactly. Move infected plant material, and you move the disease.

Eighteen forty-five, or two thousand and nine.

And now, the season.

It's November as we make this film.

Where is blight a risk right now?

In the Southern Hemisphere, it's late spring.

Potato crops in Chile, Argentina, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand are growing fast, and any warm, wet spell is blight weather. In the Northern Hemisphere, the harvest is in. The risk there sits in stores, in cull piles, and in seed for next spring.

Which brings us to the most practical part of this film.

What do farmers actually do about it?

Let's start with the thing that was missing in eighteen forty-five.

Warning. Weather-based warnings. Yes.

Because the pathogen needs warmth and moisture, you can predict risky days from the weather.

In Britain, the classic rule was the Smith Period, from nineteen fifty-six.

Two days in a row, with a minimum temperature of at least ten degrees,

and at least eleven hours each day with humidity at ninety percent or more.

And that's been updated.

Since twenty seventeen, Britain's potato industry uses the Hutton Criteria.

The same ten degrees, but only six hours of high humidity on each of the two days.

In tests against more than two thousand past outbreaks, it flagged about sixty-nine percent of them, compared with forty-one percent for the old rule.

So more early warnings.

More warnings, earlier. Other countries use their own models, like the decision systems in the Netherlands or the United States.

The idea is the same. Know when the weather favours blight, so you protect the crop before infection, not after.

But a warning isn't the same as finding it. No.

That's where scouting comes in.

Walking the field, and looking properly.

Let's give farmers a real checklist.

Where do you look first?

The places that stay wet.

Low spots, sheltered corners, field edges by hedges or trees, and parts of the field near irrigation.

Look low in the canopy, on the older leaves, where the dew lasts longest.

And what are you looking for? Pale green, water-soaked patches, often at the tip or edge of a leaf, that turn brown or black.

In the morning, check underneath.

A ring of white, downy growth around the edge of the spot is the giveaway.

Also look for dark brown lesions on the stems.

How is that different from early blight, which a lot of people confuse it with? Good question.

Early blight is a different fungus.

Its spots are usually small and dry, with rings inside like a target, and often a yellow halo.

Late blight spots are bigger, wetter, spread fast, and grow that white fuzz in humid weather.

And if you find it?

Act the same day. Tell your neighbours and your local advisory service, because your spores are their problem too.

Protect the rest of the field with a registered product, at the label dose, and rotate between different FRAC groups, so the pathogen doesn't learn to resist them.

Local advisers will know which groups still work in your area.

And beyond the field itself?

Hygiene. Many outbreaks start from cull piles, the heaps of discarded potatoes by the farmyard. They sprout in spring and blight grows on them. Cover them, or destroy them. Pull up volunteer potatoes in other crops.

And plant certified, healthy seed.

That last one is the Philadelphia-to-Flanders lesson.

Exactly.

And then there's the part that goes right back to the Andes.

Diversity. Resistant varieties.

Yes.

Wild potato relatives in Mexico and South America carry resistance genes, and breeders have been bringing them into cultivated potatoes for a century.

One well-known result is a family of varieties bred in Hungary by the Sárvári family, and developed further in Wales.

The best known, Sarpo Mira, has been on the UK's national list since two thousand and two.

And the newer approach, putting those wild genes in directly?

That's being tested.

In Ireland, the agriculture research agency Teagasc trialled a potato carrying a resistance gene from a wild relative, from twenty thirteen to twenty fifteen.

In those trials, fungicide use fell by eighty to ninety percent, without a loss of yield.

And in Africa?

In East Africa, where late blight is one of the biggest problems for

smallholders, researchers have developed a potato with three stacked resistance genes.

In Kenya it's been in field trials and under regulatory review.

As of November twenty twenty-six, we could not find an approval.

Trials have also run in Nigeria, Bangladesh and Indonesia.

So the science has moved a long way. But I want to be careful.

A resistant variety isn't a magic shield.

No. The pathogen evolves.

A single resistance gene can be overcome.

That's why breeders stack several genes, and why farmers still scout resistant crops.

And it's why diversity on the farm matters, not just in one variety.

What does diversity look like for an ordinary farm?

More than one variety, with different resistance.

Rotation, so potatoes don't follow potatoes. Other crops and income sources, so one bad season isn't a catastrophe.

And seed stores and savings, the modern version of the Andean chuño store.

And at the global level?

Genebanks.

The International Potato Center in Lima, with its nearly four thousand eight hundred traditional varieties, and backup copies of seed collections in the Svalbard Global Seed Vault in the Arctic.

And the farmers of the Andes, still growing hundreds of varieties in their own fields.

The diversity that stayed behind in fifteen sixty-seven is now the world's insurance policy.

And the world needs it. Potatoes are now grown in well over a hundred countries.

Global production is around three hundred and eighty million tonnes a year.

China and India grow the most, and potatoes are spreading fast in Africa, from Kenya to Rwanda.

So the crop that failed Ireland is now one of the foods the world depends on most.

Which is exactly why the lessons of eighteen forty-five matter.

Let's end where they matter most.

In memory.

Ireland's population kept falling for decades after the famine.

Emigration became a way of life.

Families raised children knowing many would leave.

When did it finally turn around?

Slowly, in the twentieth century. In twenty twenty-two, the census of the Republic of Ireland counted just over five point one million people.

The first time it had passed five million since eighteen fifty-one.

And the whole island?

Add Northern Ireland, with about one point nine million in its twenty twenty-one census, and the island has a little over seven million people.

Still more than a million fewer than in eighteen forty-one.

More than a hundred and eighty years later.

That's how deep it went.

In Irish, the famine is called An Gorta Mór, the Great Hunger.

Since two thousand and eight, Ireland has held a National Famine Commemoration Day each year, in a different part of the country.

And the memorials are everywhere the emigrants went.

Bronze figures on the quays in Dublin. A stone cottage from County Mayo, rebuilt on a raised hillside in lower Manhattan.

Statues in Boston, Philadelphia, Toronto and Liverpool.

And Strokestown Park, in County Roscommon, is home to the National Famine Museum, where estate papers from the famine years survive.

And the Lumper?

It's back, in a small way. In twenty thirteen, a potato grower in the Glens of Antrim, Michael McKillop, revived it from seed stock and sold it, partly as a piece of living history.

How did it taste?

Reports say floury and dry, fine for what it was. And just as vulnerable to blight as it always was. The difference now is that a farmer knows that, and can scout for it. Let's pull it together.

What does the potato famine teach a farmer, anywhere in the world, today?

First, diversity.

Don't put a whole farm, a whole region, or a whole diet on one crop, or one variety. The Andes knew that thousands of years ago.

Second, scouting and warning.

Know the weather that favours your crop's enemies, walk your fields, and act early.

David Moore saw the blight at Glasnevin, but nobody then knew what to do with the warning.

Third, clean seed and hygiene.

Diseases travel in planting material, in tubers and in transplants.

They did in eighteen forty-five, and they did in two thousand and nine.

And fourth, a lesson that's not about plants at all. A crop failure becomes a famine when people have no reserves, no income, and no help that reaches them in time.

The blight was a natural event. How many people died was decided by people.

Next time you hold a potato, think of the shore of Lake Titicaca. Of thirteen hundred varieties in one valley.

And of one variety, in one country, that wasn't enough.

Thank you for watching. If a field near you is growing potatoes this season, walk it this week. Look low, look underneath, and look early.

This video is supported by laisha.ai: free grow guides, and the Laisha Smarter app at ten US dollars a month. The link is in the description.

Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake

Ask Laisha about this

Opens Laisha's chat with your question ready to send. Sign in or start free.

Go further with Laisha Smarter

US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time

  • Ask Laisha about what you watched — up to 1,000 questions a month
  • Your own crop calendar and pest alerts
  • Every calculator and tool
10 days free for every new account, no card.